top of page
The Gardner Family

by Kelly Warman-Stallings

 

(Published to Window to the Past website on 7 January 2021)

​

Charles_Town.jpg

Charles Town, South Carolina  c/1750s

The Gardner family dates back to a man named Thomas Brown, who was born in Londonderry, County Ulster, Northern Ireland in 1702. It is unknown when Thomas Brown immigrated to the New World, but it's been estimated that he arrived in South Carolina around 1725. Not long after arriving in Charles Towne, South Carolina, Thomas met a man named George Haig from Scotland. [It is interesting to note, the name Charles Towne would later be changed to Charleston.] George Haig was a surveyor and landowner in the York District of then Craven County, South Carolina. (Charleston County would later be formed from Craven County.) 

 

Soon after, around 1730, Thomas Brown and George Haig became business partners in a large trading post near the fort along the Congaree River. They became important traders for merchants and Indians (mostly Cherokee and Catawba) alike. Some records refer to the trading post as the Congaree Factory. This was the first trading post erected in South Carolina. This area would later become known as Saxe Gothe, named for the daughter of  King Charles II. Some sources claim that Thomas' brother, Patrick Brown, also was a partner in the business, but there is no definite proof.

​

Thomas Brown married a Catawba Indian maiden sometime during the late 1720s. Some records list the Catawba Indian woman as being born in South Carolina around 1705 and the Christian name of Mary was given to her. She and Thomas had at least one confirmed child, William Brown. Other sources claim Thomas and Mary had a daughter named Elizabeth, who married a prominent man named Mr. Tweedie; they resided mostly in Georgia and South Carolina. In December of 1745, Thomas Brown wrote his last will and testament leaving everything to his son, William Brown. Thomas' estate consisted of the trading post, 300 acres of land, up to 22 slaves and around 185 horses. The practice of slavery would be passed down through the generations of Thomas Brown's descendants.

​

Thomas Brown died in 1747. It is unknown when his Catawba wife died. In that same year (1747) George Haig and William Brown, son of Thomas, were captured by the Iroquois Indian tribe who were part of the Northern Federation located in French-owned Ontario, Canada near New York and Pennsylvania. The Northern Federation of Indians also included the tribes of the MohawkOnondagaOneidaCayuga, Shawnee and Seneca; these Indian tribes were enemies of the Catawba. Some speculate this was the reason the trading post was attacked and Haig and Brown were captured. George Haig, now in his 50s, was marched into Pennsylvania at a fast pace from South Carolina and it is said that he begged the Iroquois to kill him as he could not go any farther "due to exhaustion". 

​

The fate of William Brown, who was only 17 at the time, was quite different. He was sold to the Shawnee tribe as a slave and remained with that tribe until Chief Nopkehee (aka: King Hagler) of the Catawba nation was murdered in 1763 by a Shawnee scouting party. During his imprisonment with the Shawnee he was given another captive to marry - her name was Louisa Riley and she descended from the Miami Indian tribe. Not long after Chief Nopkehee was killed in 1763, William and Louisa managed to escape from their Shawnee bondage and returned to South Carolina. That was short-lived as the Catawba shunned William because he had married into an "enemy tribe". It was during this time frame that William Brown changed his name to Jacob Gardner and left the Congaree River area, never to return.

​

With his large inheritance William/Jacob began buying land between 1766 through 1790 in Union, South Carolina, Rutherford County, North Carolina and near Bristol, Tennessee in Sullivan County before finally settling in Barren County, Kentucky. He would later sell off his land in the Carolinas and Tennessee. Not long after the Revolutionary War, Jacob and a man named James Boydstun, a Revolutionary War veteran, were employed by the Army as Indian Scouts. Jacob was not classified as a "soldier" as he was half-Indian. Jacob was located in Bristol, Tennessee during this era of time. Jacob's daughters, Nancy and Mary, married sons of James Boydstun.  By 1790, when the first U. S. Census was taken, the Gardner family was listed as residing in Rutherford County, North Carolina (present-day Henderson County).

​

William Brown/Jacob Gardner (b. 1729 SC) and Louisa Riley (b. c/1730 VA) were most likely married during the mid-1760s as their first child was born in 1766. From this wedded union Jacob and Louisa had seven children:   

​

1) Nancy Ann Gardner (1766-1854)      3) Daniel Gardner (1774-     )         5) Mary Gardner (1777-1845)          7) John Gardner (c/1780-    )

2) James Gardner (1767-      )               4) William Gardner (1775-1846).   6) Thompson Gardner (1778-1851)   

​

Note: It was through the William Gardner lineage that the Gardner family was brought to Miller County, Mo.

​

William Brown/Jacob Gardner died in Barren County, Kentucky on 5 Sep 1812. Louisa (Riley) Gardner died on 11 Aug 1798. It is unknown which state the family was living in when Louisa passed away. Their burial locations are unknown as well.

​

ky-barren-county-kentucky-1905-map.jpg

CAVE CITY

             Barren County, Kentucky            

William Gardner, son of Jacob and Louisa, was born c/1775 in North Carolina (most likely in Rutherford County). When his father [William/Jacob] died in 1812, William Gardner was residing in Barren County, Kentucky. As early as 1801 it is recorded that William and his brother, John, owned property in Barren County near Cave City (present-day Mammoth Cave National Park area). John Gardner would later leave Kentucky around the 1820s; he married Letty Woods and they eventually laid down permanent roots in Springfield, Missouri. William remained in Barren County and operated a fairly large farm; the daily farming operation was worked by slaves.

 

William was possibly married three times. His first wife, whose name was possibly Sara, died a fairly young woman having bore at least three children to William before her death. Their known children included: 1) Richard Gardner (1794-1850); 2) Jacob Riley Gardner (1800-  ); 3) Anne Gardner (1802-  ). William's second wife was Eleanor Pawling, daughter of Henry Pawling, Jr and Rebecca (Bull) Pawling.  They were married in Muhlenberg, North Carolina on 13 January 1806. Eleanor was born in North Carolina on 11 January 1779 and died on 5 January 1846 in Barren County, Kentucky. They had several children, including a set of twin daughters:    

​

1) Thompson Gardner (1807-  )       3)  Nancy Ann Gardner (1810-  )          5) Henry Pawling Gardner (1814-1887)

2) Mary Gardner (1809-1894)           4)  Jemima Gardner (1810-1847)      .   6) Mary "Polly" Gardner  (1821-1894)   

​

Note: Henry Pawling Gardner is the ancestor who brought the Gardner family to Miller County in the early 1840s. 

​

William's third wife was Sally Owen (1807 KY-1885 KY). She was the daughter of John Holland Owen. It is recorded that William and Sally were married at Doughty Creek Baptist Church in Barren County. William and Sally were wed on 21 February 1835. They had three children born to this union: 1) Juliann Gardner (1836-1888); 2) William Holland Gardner (1840-1909); 3) Sarah A. Gardner (1844-1899). There are some discrepancies in the marriage dates for William's second and third marriages. According to records, William married Eleanor Pawling in 1806 and she died in 1846. William married Sally Owen in 1835. Either the records are wrong and William did not marry a third time or William and Eleanor got divorced, which was not exactly common, but not unheard of during the 1800s.

​

Per the 1800 Census, William was residing in Warren County, Kentucky, but that proved to be a temporary home base as by 1801 William owned land in Barren County, Kentucky. William would live out the remainder of his life in this Kentucky county. William Gardner died c/1846 in Barren County. It is unknown where William Gardner and his wives are buried, but an estimated guess would be all are buried somewhere in Barren County. 

​

Henry Pawling Gardner, son of William Gardner and Eleanor (Pawling) Gardner, was born 21 July 1811 in Barren County, Kentucky. He married Susanna Keith in Edmonson County, Kentucky on 7 Jan 1836, but she died at the age of 27 in 1839. Henry and Susanna (Keith) Gardner had two sons, William Wiley Gardner (1837-    ) and Hollam Gardner (c/1839-  ). It's possible Hollam died as an infant or child as he does not show up in the 1840 census. According to family legend, after the death of his wife, Susanna (Keith) Gardner, Henry received a young slave woman named Stephanna from his father (William Gardner) to help with his young toddler (William Wiley Gardner). It was said that Stephanna remained in the household for many years and helped rear Henry's children with his second wife, Elizabeth Ann Bailey (1813-1875).

​

By 1840, Henry was residing in Warren County, Kentucky when the U. S. Census was taken. That same year Henry married Elizabeth Ann Bailey on 30 August 1840 in Barren County, Kentucky. Elizabeth Bailey was born on 13 April 1813 in Barren County and was the daughter of Julius C. Bailey (1792 VA-1860 KY) and Lucinda Ann Anderson (1793 VA-1870 MO). Lucinda evidently came to Miller County, Missouri after the death of her husband [Julius Bailey] as that is where she died in 1870.

​

Henry and Elizabeth had 10 children:

 

1) Jacob Gardner (1842-1916) married Martha Emmaline Smith

2) Lucy Ann Gardner (1843-1926) married William Harrison Smith

3) Jemima Gardner (1844-1922) married John M. Setser

4) Henry Pawling Gardner, Jr. (1847-    ) married Mary A. ______

5) Felix Bond Gardner (1850-1922) married Sarah E. ______

6) Susan E. Gardner (1851-     )

7) John May Gardner (1856-1929) married Mary Helton

8) Mary Paradine Gardner (1856-1929) married N. E. Clark

9) Nellie J. Gardner (1859-     )

10) Eleanor Gardner (1861-1897) 

​

paradine%20jemima%20lucy%20gardner_edite

L to R:  Paradine, Jemima and Lucy (c/1910)

​

Sometime between 1841 and 1842, Henry and Elizabeth left Kentucky by wagon train, taking with them a few slaves, and migrated to Miller County, Missouri. Henry's two oldest children were born in Barren County, Kentucky while the rest of the children were born in Miller County, Missouri. Henry was listed as a "farmer" in the 1870 and 1880 census. Their farm was located just northwest of Iberia and situated not far from present-day Gardner Branch (a tributary of the Tavern Creek) in what is known as today's Fairview community. 

henry p gardner.jpg

Henry Pawling Gardner, the patriarch that brought the Gardner family to Miller County, died on 16 March 1887. His wife, Elizabeth Bailey Gardner, died 6 April 1875. Both passed away near Iberia.

 

The Gardner Branch and *Gardner Cemetery were named for this pioneer family that came from Kentucky to Miller County in the early 1840s. Henry and Elizabeth are both buried at Iberia Cemetery.

​

Gardner Cemetery is a lost and forgotten cemetery.

eliz%20bailey%20gardner_edited.jpg

 

For more information about the Gardner Family, please visit the following pages: William W. Gardner, Confederate Soldier of Miller County and The Gardner, Bailey, and Allen Families of Miller County

​

bottom of page